A Review on
Microbial Control and Preservatives of Cosmetics
Patil Aachal*, Nusrat Khan
M S College of
Pharmacy, Devghar, Maharashtra, India.
Abstract: Microbial control and the use of
preservatives are crucial aspects of cosmetic formulation, ensuring product
safety and longevity. Microbiological safety is paramount to protect
consumers from potential harm caused by pathogenic microorganisms,
contributing to overall product quality and public health. Various
strategies, including chemical, physical, or physicochemical methods, are
employed to ensure microbiological safety, controlling and eliminating
harmful microorganisms. Contamination of cosmetics by microorganisms can
lead to spoilage, degradation, and potential harm to consumers. The
presence of microorganisms can induce changes in taste, smell, texture, and
overall product quality. Some microorganisms may even produce toxins,
posing health risks if consumed. Preventing and addressing contamination is
essential to maintain the quality and safety of cosmetic products. Preservatives
play a vital role in preventing the growth of harmful microorganisms such
as bacteria, fungi, yeast, mold, and algae, which can cause product
spoilage or skin infections. Common preservatives used in cosmetics include
parabens, phenoxyethanol, benzyl alcohol, organic acids, and formaldehyde.
These ingredients help extend the shelf life of products and ensure they
remain safe for use. In pharmaceutical dosage forms, including liquid
preparations such as aqueous solutions, suspensions, syrups, emulsions,
creams, and semisolids, preservatives are widely employed to maintain
microbial safety. The main function of antimicrobial preservatives is to
inhibit the growth of unwanted microorganisms, contributing to the overall
stability and safety of pharmaceutical and cosmetic products. Preserving
cosmetic products is essential not only for maintaining their quality but
also for safeguarding the well-being of consumers. The careful selection
and use of preservatives are key considerations in cosmetic formulation,
ensuring that products meet safety standards and remain effective
throughout their intended shelf life.
Keywords: preservatives in cosmetics,
microbiological safety, microbiological purity, antimicrobial agent.
|
Article History
Received: 25/10/2023
Revised: 05/11/2023 Accepted: 15/11/2023 Published: 31/12/2023
|
INTRODUCTION:
Cosmetics are products designed for use on
various external parts of the human body, including the skin, hair, nails,
lips, and external genital organs, as well as teeth and mucous membranes in the
oral cavity. They serve purposes such as altering a person's appearance,
cleaning the body, perfuming the body, maintaining skin health, addressing body
odor, and providing skin protection[1].
Cosmetic products, especially those
containing water, oils, peptides, and carbohydrates, can provide a favorable
environment for bacteria and fungi to grow. Proper storage and hygiene are
crucial to prevent contamination and ensure the safety of these products[2].
preservation is essential to prevent microbial growth in cosmetic products.
Preservatives are added to inhibit the growth of bacteria (both gram-positive
and gram-negative), yeast, and mold, which can spoil the product and
potentially lead to skin infections or other health issues when applied to the
skin. Properly preserved cosmetics are safer for consumers to use[3]. the term
"preservative" is derived from the Latin word "conservo,"
which means "to preserve." As the name suggests, preservatives play a
crucial role in ensuring the microbiological safety of cosmetic products
throughout their shelf life and during their use by preventing the growth of
harmful microorganisms. This helps maintain the product's quality and safety
for consumers[4]. Safety is paramount when selecting preservatives for cosmetic
products, as they must be safe for human health. Primary contamination
typically occurs during the manufacturing process, where impurities or
microorganisms can inadvertently get introduced. This emphasizes the need for
strict quality control and hygiene during production. Secondary contamination,
on the other hand, can happen when consumers use the product. For instance,
when fingers or applicators come into contact with the product, they can
introduce bacteria from the skin into the product. This highlights the
importance of user education and proper product handling to minimize the risk
of secondary contamination. Preservatives in cosmetics serve the critical role
of reducing the risk of microbial contamination in the product. They help
maintain the product's safety, quality, and efficacy throughout its shelf life and
during its use by consumers. This is crucial for ensuring that cosmetic
products remain suitable and safe for the intended purpose[5].bacteria, yeasts
and molds are naturally present in our environment and on our skin.
Contamination of cosmetic products with these microorganisms can indeed lead to
significant problems, especially for products applied around the eyes or on the
skin. Preservatives, which are antimicrobial ingredients, are essential in most
cosmetic products to prevent damage caused bymicroorganisms and to safeguard
against contamination by consumers during use. They play a crucial role in
maintaining product safety and quality[6]. In addition to their role as
antimicrobial agents, preservatives can also function as antioxidants.
Antioxidants are added to cosmetic products to protect them from damage and degradation caused by
exposure to oxygen, which can lead to issues like product discoloration or
changes in texture. So, preservatives can serve a dual purpose in maintaining
the quality and stability of cosmetic products. Without preservatives, cosmetic
products are susceptible to contamination, similar to food. This can lead to
product spoilage and, more importantly, can pose a risk of irritation,
infections, or other adverse reactions when applied to the skin. Preservatives
play a crucial role in ensuring the safety and longevity of cosmetic
products[7].preservatives are especially essential in products with higher
water content because they help prevent alteration and degradation by microorganisms
during storage. Without preservatives, these products would be more prone to
spoilage and microbial contamination, which could affect their quality and
safety [8]. Chemical preservatives can help slow down the spoilage of products
by inhibiting the growth of microorganisms. However, they may not completely
prevent spoilage over an extended period. Proper storage and handling are also
important factors in preserving the freshness of products [9]. Antimicrobial
preservatives work by inhibiting or killing microorganisms to prevent spoilage.
Their effectiveness is tied to their ability to be toxic to live cells,
including bacteria and fungi, which is the reason they are used in
preservation. Balancing their toxicity with the safety for human consumption is
a critical consideration in food and product preservation [10]. when potential
pathogens contaminate a product, it renders it unsafe for use and spoiled.
However, in the context of your paper, the focus is primarily on the
degradation caused by contaminating microorganisms that may not necessarily
pose an immediate health risk but can still lead to the deterioration of the
product's quality and shelf life. This degradation aspect is important to
consider in various industries to maintain product quality and safety [11]. factors
that can influence the mean life of a product. These factors encompass various
aspects like microbial growth, temperature control, moisture content, exposure
to light and oxygen, fermentation, acidification, and enzymatic changes, all of
which can contribute to the deterioration of a product's quality and safety
over time. Managing these factors is crucial in preserving the properties of
finished products and extending their shelf life [12]. Extended storage can
indeed lead to the deterioration of a product, affecting its stability and
causing a decline in its intended quality. Microbial contamination can be a
significant contributor to this decline, potentially rendering the product
harmful to consumers if not properly preserved and handled. This highlights the
importance of effective preservation methods and quality control measures to
ensure product safety and longevity [13]. Cosmetic products are designed to be
applied to the external parts of the human body, including skin, hair, nails,
as well as areas like the teeth, oral cavity, or mucous membranes, with the
primary purpose of enhancing or maintaining their appearance. These products
can include a wide range of items like makeup, skincare products, perfumes, and
more [14]. cosmetics products are typically formulated using a combination of
chemicals to enhance the appearance or fragrance of the human body. These
products can include items like makeup, skincare products, perfumes, and more,
all designed to improve or alter various aspects of one's appearance or scent
[15]. cosmetics market has expanded globally, with a notable growth in India.
The influx of international brands and the focus on ecofriendly and ayurvedic
ingredients indeed play a significant role in this expansion. India's emerging
market potential is a key factor in this growth[16].
The development of
microbial resistance to preservatives in pharmaceutical and cosmetic products
is a concerning issue. This highlights the need for continuous research and
innovation in the development of effective preservation methods to ensure
product safety and longevity. Monitoring and adapting to emerging microbial
resistance is crucial in maintaining product quality and safety standards [17].
Why do we need
preservatives in cosmetics?
Preservatives are
indeed used in various products to prevent contamination and extend their shelf
life.
When products like
skincare items or cosmetics come into contact with our skin, they can
potentially introduce bacteria or other microorganisms, especially if the skin
is damaged or broken. Preservatives help to inhibit the growth of these
microorganisms, ensuring the safety of the products when applied to the skin or
near sensitive areas like the eyes. Additionally, they help maintain product
quality over time.
Several factors can
contribute to the spoilage of finished products, especially in industries like
skincare and cosmetics:
Skin Microflora:
The natural microorganisms on our skin can contaminate products when they come
into contact with it. Preservatives help prevent the growth of these
microorganisms.
Hygienic
Conditions: The cleanliness and hygiene of the production environment and
equipment are crucial in preventing contamination during manufacturing.
Raw Materials: The
quality and source of raw materials used in the production process can impact
product spoilage. Contaminated or low-quality raw materials can lead to
microbial growth. By addressing these factors and implementing proper quality
control measures, manufacturers can reduce the risk of spoilage and ensure the
safety and efficacy of their products.
Products that
contain water or other compounds susceptible to contamination, like creams,
solutions, emulsions, suspensions, parental and eye drops, are at a higher risk
of spoilage. To mitigate this risk and preserve their quality and safety, the
addition of preservatives is often necessary. These preservatives help prevent
microbial growth and degradation, ensuring that the product retains its
intended properties and remains safe for use[18].
Preservatives
are essential components in cosmetics for several reasons:
1.Microbial Safety:
Cosmetics contain water, oils, and various ingredients that can provide an
ideal environment for the growth of bacteria, mold, and yeast. Preservatives
help prevent microbial contamination, ensuring that the product remains safe
for use.
2.Shelf Life
Extension: Cosmetics, like other products, have a limited shelf life.
Preservatives extend this shelf life by inhibiting the growth of
microorganisms, allowing consumers to use the product over an extended period.
3.Product Quality:
Preservatives help maintain the product's quality, appearance, and texture by
preventing spoilage and the development of unpleasant odors or changes in color
and consistency.
4.User Safety:
Without preservatives, cosmetics could become a breeding ground for harmful
bacteria, increasing the risk of skin infections or other health issues when
applied to the skin or near mucous membranes.
Overall,
preservatives play a crucial role in ensuring the safety, efficacy, and
longevity of cosmetic products. However, it's important to use them in
appropriate concentrations to minimize any potential side effects or allergic
reactions.
Preservatives may
be used in cosmetics to prevent the growth of harmful bacteria and mold [ 19].
Fragrance:-
Preservatives can be present in perfumes and colognes to prevent the growth of
microbes in the fragrance formulation itself.
Lipstick:-
Lipsticks can contain preservatives to ensure the product remains stable and
safe to use over time, even in a moist environment.
Shampoo and
Conditioner:- These hair care products often contain preservatives to prevent
the growth of bacteria, fungi, and yeast, especially due to their water-based
nature.
Lotion and
Moisturizer:- Preservatives are common in creams and lotions to maintain their
quality and safety by preventing microbial contamination.
Hair Gel:- Hair
gels use preservatives to keep their consistency intact and to ensure they do
not become a breeding ground for microbes.
Nail Polish:-
Preservatives help maintain the integrity of nail polish by preventing clumping
or separation of the ingredients.
Facial and Shower
Cleaner:- These products often contain preservatives to prevent the growth of
bacteria, mold, and other microbes that can thrive in a moist environment,
ensuring the product remains effective and safe to use.
Nail Glue:- Nail
glue may use preservatives to maintain its adhesive properties and prevent
spoilage. Baby Shampoo:- Baby shampoos typically include preservatives to keep
them free from harmful microorganisms and maintain their safety for sensitive
baby skin.
Color Cosmetics:-
Color cosmetics such as eyeshadows, blushes, and foundations can contain
preservatives to prevent bacterial contamination and maintain product
consistency.
Anti-Aging
Products:- Preservatives are commonly used in anti-aging creams and serums to
ensure the stability and longevity of active ingredients, as these products are
often used over an extended period.
List of
preservatives in cosmetics:
Parabens
which are commonly
used preservatives in various cosmetic and personal care products.
Examples:-
Methylparaben, propylparaben, and butylparaben are indeed part of this group.
They are effective
at preventing the growth of fungi and some gram-positive bacteria in these
products. However, there has been some concern about their safety and potential
health risks, which has led to increased scrutiny and the development of
alternative preservatives in recent years[20].
Formaldahyde
Example:-
DMDM hydantoin,
imidazolidinyl urea, and diazolidinyl urea are indeed commonly used
preservatives.
They are more
effective against bacteria but have weaker efficacy against fungi compared to
parabens. These ingredients help extend the shelf life of various cosmetics and
personal care items by preventing bacterial growth. It's important for
consumers to be aware of the ingredients in their products and any potential
sensitivities or allergic reactions[21].
Organic acids
Example:-
Benzoic Acid/Sodium
Benzoate: These are commonly used preservatives, with sodium benzoate being a
water-soluble form of benzoic acid. They are effective against a wide range of
microorganisms and are often used in acidic products like soft drinks and salad
dressings.
Sorbic
Acid/Potassium Sorbate: Sorbic acid and potassium sorbate are used to inhibit
the growth of molds, yeast, and some bacteria in food and personal care
products. They are particularly effective in acidic conditions.
Levulinic Acid:
Levulinic acid can function as a preservative and is often used in combination
with other preservatives. It's derived from renewable resources and considered
more environmentally friendly.
Anisic Acid: Anisic
acid is used as a fragrance ingredient and as a preservative in cosmetics and
personal care products. It helps prevent microbial growth and extends product
shelf life.
As you mentioned,
some of these preservatives may require higher concentrations to be effective,
which can lead to increased production costs. Balancing cost-effectiveness with
product safety and stability is a common challenge for manufacturers[22].
Importance of
preservatives in cosmetics:
1)To kill or
inhibit the growth of microorganisms and protect a formula from microbial
contamination, you can consider the following measures:
Sterilization: Use
methods like autoclaving, pasteurization, or sterile filtration to eliminate or
reduce microorganisms in the product and its packaging.
Preservatives: Add
antimicrobial agents like parabens, benzalkonium chloride, or potassium sorbate
to the formula to prevent the growth of microorganisms.
pH Adjustment:
Adjust the pH of the formula to levels that are unfavorable for the growth of
specific microorganisms.
Aseptic Processing:
Implement aseptic techniques and environments during manufacturing and
packaging to prevent contamination.
Packaging: Use
sterile containers and packaging materials, and ensure they are sealed properly
to prevent contamination during storage and distribution.
Hygiene: Enforce
strict hygiene practices among personnel involved in production to minimize the
introduction of microorganisms.
Quality Control:
Regularly test and monitor the product for microbial contamination using appropriate
methods.
Environmental
Control: Maintain a clean and controlled production environment to minimize the
risk of contamination[ 23].
2)bacteria, fungi,
and yeast. They help Preservatives are ingredients added to products to protect
them against the growth of extend the shelf life of products by inhibiting or
slowing down the growth of microorganisms that can spoil the product or make it
unsafe for use. Preservatives are commonly used in various industries,
including food, cosmetics, and pharmaceuticals, to maintain product quality and
safety [24].
3)Preservatives are added to products at low
levels to prevent the growth of harmful microorganisms and extend the product's
shelf life, allowing consumers to use it safely over a longer period [25].
4)Without
preservatives, personal care products could become contaminated with
microorganisms or degrade from the adverse effects of oxygen [26].
Ideal Properties
of Preservatives:
1)
That doesn't cause skin irritation.
2)
It should be non-toxic.
3)
It should maintain its physical and chemical stability[27].
4)
The preservatives must be harmonious with the other components in the
formulation[28].
5)
It should function effectively as an antimicrobial agent with a broad spectrum
of activity[29].
6)
It should possess potency as a preservative even in small concentrations.
7)
It should sustain its effectiveness during the entire product manufacturing
process, shelf life, and various uses.
8)
It should exhibit a wide-ranging antimicrobial activity against both bacteria
and fungi[30].
9)
It should demonstrate exceptional antimicrobial efficacy when used at low
levels in cosmetic products[31].
10)
It must remain inert and not react with other components in the formula or the
container material[32].
11)
It should be compatible with virtually all cosmetic materials and not impact
the color or fragrance of the final products.
12) It should offer
a cost-effective and readily available solution.
Mechanisms of
action of antimicrobial preservatives:-
Preservatives,
whether natural or synthetic, can have various modes of action to prevent
spoilage and extend the shelf life of products.
1.
One of
these modes of action is cell wall lysis and leakage, which can be associated
with substances like phenols and organomercurials. These compounds disrupt
microbial cell membranes, leading to cell damage and leakage of cellular
contents, ultimately inhibiting microbial growth.
2.
Cross-linkage,
as seen with glutaraldehyde, involves creating chemical bonds within proteins
or other cellular components, which can interfere with the functioning of
microorganisms.
3.
Interference
with the integrity of the cell membrane can occur through compounds like EDTA
and quaternary ammonium compounds, disrupting the structure of microbial cell membranes
and rendering them nonfunctional.
4.
Inhibition
of folic acid synthesis is another mechanism used by preservatives such as
paraben and benzoic acid. These substances interfere with the microbial
synthesis of folic acid, an essential component for DNA synthesis and cell
growth, effectively inhibiting
5.
microbial
proliferation. These various modes of action help preservatives prevent the
growth and spoilage of microorganisms in products[33].
Classification
of preservatives:
Preservatives are
classified on variety of the basis and some of these are as follows.
A.
CLASSIFICATION BASED ON MECHANISM OF
ACTION
1. Antioxidants:
Antioxidants are
substances that prevent or slow down the oxidation of other compounds,
including active pharmaceutical ingredients. Oxidation can lead to the
degradation of sensitive substances when they are exposed to oxygen.
Examples of
antioxidants include Vitamin E, Vitamin C, Butylatedhydroxyanisole (BHA), and
Butylatedhydroxytoluene (BHT).
They help protect
sensitive substances from deterioration caused by oxidation.
2. Antimicrobial
agents:
Antimicrobial
agents are substances that are active against both gram-positive and
gram-negative microorganisms, which can cause the degradation of pharmaceutical
preparations when present in small amounts.
Examples of
antimicrobial agents include benzoates, sodium benzoate, and sorbates.
These agents help
prevent microbial contamination and preserve the quality and safety of
pharmaceutical products.
3. Chelating
agents:
Chelating agents
are substances that can form complexes with metal ions, which helps prevent the
degradation of pharmaceutical formulations by binding and inactivating these
metal ions.
Examples of
chelating agents include Disodium ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA),
polyphosphates, and citric acid.
They are used to
improve the stability and shelf life of pharmaceutical products by preventing
metal-catalyzed reactions that could lead to degradation.
B.
CLASSIFICATION BASED ON SOURCE
1. Natural
Preservatives:-
natural
preservatives are derived from natural sources such as plants, minerals, or
animals, and they are used to extend the shelf life of various products,
including pharmaceuticals.
Examples you
mentioned like neem oil, salt (sodium chloride), lemon, and honey are commonly
used natural preservatives.
They help inhibit
the growth of microorganisms and oxidation, thus preserving the quality and
safety of products.
2. Artificial
Preservatives:
Artificial
preservatives, also known as synthetic or chemical preservatives, are
human-made compounds synthesized through chemical processes. They are effective
in preventing the growth of various microorganisms when used in small
concentrations.
Examples include
benzoates, sodium benzoate, sorbates, propionates, and nitrites. These preservatives are commonly used in various products to extend
their shelf life and maintain their safety and quality[34].
Types of susceptible products used in
cosmetics:-
The diversity of pharmaceutical and cosmetic
products, as well as the various microorganisms that can cause spoilage, makes
each spoilage incident unique. Generalizations about susceptible products can
be inaccurate, especially with the inclusion of sophisticated and biodegradable
ingredients. However, certain types of products are more susceptible to
spoilage by specific organisms based on experience. It's important to closely
monitor and test products to ensure their quality and safety.
Liquids
A ) water
Water is essential for life, and it plays a
crucial role in metabolic reactions. Bacteria, being aquatic organisms, thrive
in environments with high water concentrations. This makes products with a lot
of free water vulnerable to bacterial spoilage. Proper preservation and storage
are essential to prevent this. the water provided by regulated water suppliers
in many countries typically meets high microbiological quality standards,
making it suitable for use in pharmaceuticals and cosmetics manufacturing.
Interestingly, low-conductivity water, often produced through processes like
distillation or deionization for enhanced chemical purity, can actually pose a
greater risk of microbiological contamination due to its lack of minerals and
ions that can inhibit microbial growth. Proper handling and monitoring are
crucial to ensure the safety and quality of water used in these industries.
Without proper treatment and precautions to
minimize contamination, water can quickly become a breeding ground for various
microorganisms. Initially, both Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria can
multiply rapidly, followed by the proliferation of a wide range of bacteria,
molds, and yeast. This underscores the importance of water quality control and
treatment in various industries to prevent such microbial proliferation [36].
B)suspensions
Aqueous suspensions of inorganic materials
in pharmaceuticals can indeed provide an environment conducive to microbial
growth. The added preservatives might be absorbed or inactivated by the
suspended matter, making it challenging to prevent contamination. Unlike
visible surface mold, microbial growth within these products can go unnoticed
due to their opacity.
Spoilage may only become apparent when an
offensive odor or unpleasant taste is detected upon opening the container,
potentially leading to unwitting ingestion of a high bacterial load. This
highlights the importance of rigorous quality control and microbial testing in
pharmaceutical production to ensure product safety[37].
C)emulsions
Oil-in-water (O/W)
emulsions are indeed susceptible to spoilage because the presence of water in
the continuous phase can facilitate the spread of contaminants throughout the
product. Preservatives primarily exert their protective effects within this
aqueous phase and at its boundaries. However, their effectiveness depends on
factors such as their solubility in the specific oil and water used in the
emulsion and the ratio of oil to water. Ensuring the right choice and
concentration of preservatives is essential to maintain the stability and
safety of O/W emulsions in various products like cosmetics and
pharmaceuticals[38].
Besides partition
effects, the activity of preservatives can be further reduced by inactivation
due to various compounds, including nonionic emulsifiers. These emulsifiers
often have minimal bactericidal activity and can even serve as a nutrient
source for certain bacteria like Pseudomonas species, which can lead to further
microbial proliferation. It's crucial for product formulation to take into
account these interactions to ensure the effectiveness of preservatives in
preventing microbial contamination and spoilage [39]. some materials used in
emulsions can be susceptible to microbial degradation. Emulsions often consist
of a combination of water and oil, and if not properly preserved or formulated,
they can provide a favorable environment for microorganisms to grow.
Emulsifiers, stabilizers, and certain additives can also be vulnerable to
microbial contamination.
To prevent this, preservatives
are often added to emulsions to inhibit microbial growth and extend their shelf
life. It's essential to follow good manufacturing practices when formulating
emulsions to ensure their microbial stability. Spoilage in emulsions can
manifest in various ways, including changes in rheological properties, such as
separation or "breaking down" of the emulsion. Other signs of
spoilage may include discoloration, decolorization, alterations in odor and
taste, and visible signs of microbial growth. These changes are indicative of
the deterioration of the emulsion's quality and safety, and they are common
reasons for products to be considered unsuitable for consumption or use. Proper
storage, handling, and formulation can help prolong the shelf life and maintain
the quality of emulsions.
D)creams and
lotions
Cosmetic and
toiletry preparations can be complex, and they often contain a wide range of
ingredients. The use of natural substances like animal proteins and vitamins in
these products has become a common trend. However, it's important to be aware
that such natural ingredients can be nutrient sources for microorganisms,
potentially inactivating preservatives and leading to contamination. Glycerol,
a common ingredient in both pharmaceutical and cosmetic formulations, is also
susceptible to microbial metabolism, especially when water is present. This can
create an environment conducive to microbial growth. As a result, manufacturers
must carefully formulate and preserve these products to ensure their safety and
shelf life. Preservatives and other antimicrobial agents are often added to
prevent microbial contamination and spoilage in cosmetic and toiletry
preparations.
Mould growth is
indeed a common cause of spoilage in various types of creams, including
antifungal, calamine, baby, hair, moisture, and cleansing creams. Several
factors can contribute to this issue: Container Contamination: Mould spores can
enter creams through contaminated containers or packaging materials. Proper
cleaning and sterilization of containers before filling them with cream are
essential to prevent contamination.
Air Spaces: Large
air spaces within the product packaging can provide opportunities for mould
spores to settle and grow. Reducing excess air in containers and using airless
packaging can help mitigate this issue.
Poor Storage
Conditions: Creams are often sensitive to temperature and humidity
fluctuations. Storing these products in humid or warm environments can promote
mould growth. Maintaining proper storage conditions, such as cool and dry
areas, is crucial.
Preservation
Challenges: Creams typically contain water, which is a key ingredient for mould
growth. Preservatives are added to inhibit microbial growth, but their effectiveness
can be compromised by factors like container contamination or excess air.
E)Ointments and
oils
anhydrous
materials, in theory, do not support the growth of microorganisms because they
lack water, which is essential for most microbial growth. However, in practice,
when anhydrous products like oils and ointments are filled into containers with
large air spaces, there is a possibility of mould spoilage. This is because
moulds can utilize atmospheric moisture, and the presence of humidity or
accidental ingress of water can create conditions conducive to their growth.
While the incidence of mould spoilage in anhydrous products is lower compared
to creams, it can still occur. Mould colonies can sometimes be found on the
surfaces of ointments, including products like white petroleum jelly and even
fungicidal ointments, which are ironically intended to combat fungal
infections. To prevent mould growth in anhydrous products, manufacturers should
take measures to minimize the introduction of moisture during production and
packaging. Additionally, proper sealing of containers and storing products in
dry environments can help reduce the risk of mould contamination. oils are at a
slightly greater risk of microbial contamination compared to ointments. This is
because oils are more fluid and less viscous, which allows condensed water to
carry microorganisms to the bottom of the container, where they can become
trapped. This trapped moisture can create localized pockets of humidity within
the oil, providing an environment where microorganisms can potentially grow[40]
F) shampoos
Shampoos can indeed
be susceptible to contamination by various Gram-negative waterborne bacteria.
These bacteria are a concern because they are often found in water sources and
can thrive in moist environments. When shampoos come into contact with
contaminated water during manufacturing, packaging, or usage, these bacteria
can be introduced into the product. To prevent contamination, manufacturers of
shampoos typically employ strict quality control and sanitation procedures.
This includes using purified water in formulations, maintaining clean
production facilities, and implementing quality assurance protocols to test for
microbial contamination. Consumers can also play a role in preventing contamination
by ensuring that shampoo bottles and containers are kept tightly sealed when
not in use and avoiding introducing potentially contaminated water into the
product. Proper storage and hygiene practices can help maintain the safety and
quality of shampoo products[41].
G) syrups
the high sugar
content in syrups can inhibit the growth of many microorganisms due to its high
osmotic pressure. This high osmotic pressure essentially draws water out of
microorganisms, preventing their growth and proliferation. However, as you
mentioned, there are osmotolerant moulds and yeasts that can withstand these
high sugar concentrations. These microorganisms have adapted to survive in
environments with high osmotic pressure, such as sugary syrups. When they contaminate
syrup products, they can cause spoilage and lead to issues like off-flavors or
changes in texture. To prevent contamination and spoilage in syrups,
manufacturers often implement proper hygiene and sanitation practices during
production and packaging. They may also use preservatives to inhibit the growth
of osmotolerant microorganisms. Additionally, storing syrups in sealed
containers and in cool, dry conditions can help maintain their quality and
shelf life [42].
solids
A) powders
The spoilage of
powdered products can occur when they are exposed to damp conditions, leading
to visible mold growth. This can potentially result in microbial contamination
and poses a risk of illness, especially if Clostridia spores are present. While
there is no clear evidence linking contaminants to irritation from cosmetic
powders, it is generally undesirable to have more than a few hundred organisms
per gram in these products. Powders intended for use on broken skin or in the
eye area should be made from sterilized raw materials as an extra precaution [43].
B)solid cosmetics
Lipsticks, despite
containing preservatives, can still be susceptible to mold growth, often
occurring inside the lipstick case, especially after the product becomes
moistened by breath during use. Moisture, possibly from saliva, can also
initiate mold growth in mascara preparations, which can harbor many bacteria.
Contamination risks are associated with the brushes used in makeup application,
as they can pick up organisms from the skin during use. Similar concerns apply
to solid cakes of makeup. In these situations, the effectiveness of
preservatives may be limited, possibly because they are absorbed into the solid
material. Moreover, their concentration must be carefully controlled to avoid
potential irritation to the eyes.
CONCLUSIONS
When it comes to
microbial control and preservatives in cosmetics, the main goal is to prevent
the growth of harmful bacteria, fungi, and other microorganisms. This helps to
ensure the safety and shelf life of cosmetic products. Various preservatives
are used in cosmetics to achieve this, such as parabens, phenoxyethanol, and
benzyl alcohol. These preservatives work by inhibiting the growth and
reproduction of microorganisms. It's important for cosmetic companies to follow
strict regulations and guidelines to ensure the safety and effectiveness of
their products.
REFERENCE
1.
European
Union. Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 of the European Parliament and of the
Council. Official Journal of the European Union. 2009;L(342):59.
2.
Halla
N, Fernandes IP, Heleno SA, Costa P, Boucherit-Otmani Z, Boucherit K, et al.
Cosmetics preservation: a review on present strategies. Molecules.
2018;23(7):1571.
3.
Mufti
J, Cernasov D, Macchio R. Preserving personal care and household products.
Household and Personal Products Industry. 2001;38(5):69.
4.
Curry
J, Brannan D, Geis P. History of cosmetic microbiology. In: Geis P, editor.
Cosmetic Microbiology: A Practical Approach. Florida: CRC Press; 1993. p. 3-17.
5.
Na'was
T, Alkofahi A. Microbial contamination and preservative efficacy of topical
creams. J Clin Pharm Ther. 1994;19(1):41-46.
6.
Al-Gabr
HM, Zheng T, Yu X. Fungi contamination of drinking water. Rev Environ Contam
Toxicol. 2013;228:121-139.
7.
Molecules.
2018 Jul;23(7):1571. Published online 2018 Jun 28. doi:
10.3390/molecules23071571.
8.
Gragg
SE, Brashears MM. In: Encyclopedia of Meat Sciences. Second Edition. 2014.
9.
Sivakumar
S, Kaur H. College of Dairy Science and Technology (CoDST), Guru Angad Dev
Veterinary and Animal Sciences University (GADVASU), Ludhiana,141004, Punjab,
India.
10.
Chiori
CO, Ghobashy AA. A potentiating effect of EDTA on the bactericidal activity of
lower concentrations of ethanol. Int J Pharm. 1983;17(2-3):121-128.
11.
Uerpmann-Wittzack
R. European Directorate for the Quality of Medicines and Healthcare (EDQM).
2017.
12.
Barnes
JM. Aflatoxin as a health hazard. J Appl Bacteriol. 1970;33(2):285-98.
13.
Yoshioka
S, Stella VJ. Stability of drugs and dosage forms. Springer Science &
Business Media. 2000.
14.
Blanchin
A, Chareyron C, Levert Q. The customer behaviour in men's cosmetics market.
2007.
15.
de Groot, A. C., & White, I. R. (2001).
Cosmetics and skin care products. Textbook of contact dermatitis, 661-685.
16.
Indian
Cosmetic Market Outlook 2018 (2014),
https://www.rncos.com/Market-Analysis-Reports/Indian-Cosmetic-Market-Outlook-2018-IM705.htm.
Accessed 2 Feb, 2019
17.
Piper,
P., Mahé, Y., Thompson, S., Pandjaitan, R., Holyoak, C., Egner, R., ... &
Kuchler, K. (1998). The Pdr12 ABC transporter is required for the development
of weak organic acid resistance in yeast. The EMBO journal, 17(15), 4257-4265.
18.
Zani,
F., Minutello, A., Maggi, L., Santi, P., & Mazza, P. (1997). Evaluation of
preservative effectiveness in pharmaceutical products: the use of a wild strain
of Pseudomonas cepacia. Journal of applied microbiology, 83(3), 322-326.
19.
Khatkar,
A., Nanda, A., & Narasimhan, B. (2013). EVALUATION OF PRESERVATIVE
EFFECTIVENESS OF FERULIC ACID DERIVATIVES IN ALUMINIUM HYDROXIDE GEL-USP.
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research, 4(7), 2721.
20.
Harley,
K. G., Kogut, K., Madrigal, D. S., Cardenas, M., Vera, I. A., Meza-Alfaro, G.,
... & Parra, K. L. (2016). Reducing phthalate, paraben, and phenol exposure
from personal care products in adolescent girls: findings from the HERMOSA
intervention study. Environmental health perspectives, 124(10), 1600-1607.
21.
De
Groot, A. C., & Veenstra, M. (2010). Formaldehyde‐releasers in cosmetics in
the USA and in Europe. Contact Dermatitis, 62(4), 221-224.
22.
National
Institutes of Health. (1996). Molecules: a journal of synthetic chemistry and
natural product chemistry.
23.
Cason,
J. (1954). Synthetic Methods of Organic Chemistry. Journal of the American
Chemical Society, 76(1), 317-317.
24.
Herman,
A. (2019). Antimicrobial ingredients as preservative booster and components of
self-preserving cosmetic products. Current microbiology, 76(6), 744-754.
25.
Nasser,
L. A. (2008). Fungal profiles isolated from open and used cosmetic products collected
from different localities in Saudi Arabia. Saudi Journal of Biological
Sciences, 15.
26.
Mufti,
J., Cernasov, D., & Macchio, R. (2001). Preserving personal care and
household products. Household and Personal Products Industry, v38, (5), p69. 23
27.
Epstein,
H. (2006). Cosmetics preservation: sense and nonsense. Clinics in Dermatology,
24(6), 551-552.
28.
Orth,
D. S. (1981). Principles of preservative efficacy testing.
29.
Adams,
H. J., Mastri, A. R., & Charron, D. (1977). Morphological effects of
subarachnoid methylparaben on rabbit spinal cord. Pharmacological Research
Communications, 9(6), 547-551.
30.
Aeling,
J. L., & Nuss, D. D. (1974). Systemic eczematous contact type dermatitis
medicamentosa caused by parabens. Archives of dermatology, 110(4), 640-640.
31.
Nielsen,
P. B., Müllertz, A., Norling, T., & Kristensen, H. G. (2001). The effect of
α-tocopherol on the in vitro solubilisation of lipophilic drugs. International
journal of pharmaceutics, 222(2), 217-224.
32.
Brul,
S., & Coote, P. (1999). Preservative agents in foods: mode of action and
microbial resistance mechanisms. International journal of food microbiology,
50(1-2), 1-17.
33.
Constantinides,
P. P., Tustian, A., & Kessler, D. R. (2004). Tocol emulsions for drug
solubilization and parenteral delivery. Advanced drug delivery reviews, 56(9),
1243-1255.
34.
Wilson,
L.A, A.J. Jilian and D.G. Ahearu, The survival and growth of microorganisms in
mascara during use, Am, J. Ophthalmol, (79). 1975, 591-601.
35.
Shooter,
R. A., Gaya, H., Cooke, E. M., Kumar, P., Patel, N., Parker, M. T., ... &
France, D. (1969). Food and medicaments as possible sources of hospital strains
of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The Lancet, 293(7608), 1227-1229.
36.
Guyne,
C. J. and Bennet, E. O. Bacterial deterioration of emulsion oils. Appl.
Microbiol. 7 117 No. 2 (1959).
37.
Bean,
H. S. (1967). The microbiology of topical preparations in pharmaceutical
practice. 2. Pharmaceutical aspects. Pharmaceutical Journal, 199, 289-292.
38.
And,
M. B., & Tice, L. F. (1957). The preservation of aqueous preparations
containing nonionic surfactants I. Growth of microorganisms in solutions and
dispersions of nonionic surfactants. Journal of the American Pharmaceutical
Association, 46(7), 442-445.
39.
Tice,
L. F., & Barr, M. (1958). Factors to be considered in the preservation of
cosmetic emulsions. J Soc Cosmet Chem, 9, 171-180. 24
40.
RIVERS,
S. M., & Walters, V. (1966). The effect of benzoic acid, phenol and
hydroxybenzoates on the oxygen uptake and growth of some lipolytic fungi.
Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology, 18(Supplement_1), 45S-51S.
41.
Eggins,
H. O. W., & Walker, V. (1963). The decomposition of pharmaceutical
emulsions by fungi. West Afr J Biol Chem, 7, 2-8.
42.
Bryce,
D. M., & Smart, R. (1965). The preservation of shampoos. J. Soc. Cosmetic
Chemists, 1(6), 187-201.
43.
Welthagen,
J. J., & Viljoen, B. C. (1999). The isolation and identification of yeasts
obtained during the manufacture and ripening of Cheddar cheese. Food
Microbiology, 16(1), 63-73.